CDFAM NYC 2023 · New York · 14–15 June 2023

Mud y Robots: Keynote Presentation

Abstract

CDFAM Computational Design (+DfAM) Symposium, June 14-15, 2023

Professor Ronald Rael is the Eva Li Memorial Chair in Architecture at the University of California Berkeley. He is an architect, author, and thought leader in additive manufacturing, borderwall studies, and earthen architecture. He is the co-founder of Emerging Objects, a creatively-driven design consultancy specializing in innovations in 3D printing architecture, building components, environments, and products; and FORUST, a company focused on 3D printing wood. His new initiative, Muddy Robots, is a new paradigm in building construction, coupling humankind’s oldest building material with advanced additive manufacturing technology to create housing that can save the planet.

His work is part of the permanent collection at the Museum of Modern Art and the San Francisco, the Cooper Hewitt, and the Smithsonian American Art Museum Renwick Gallery has acquired their series, Bad Ombres v.2. Rael has authored several books, including Printing Architecture: Innovative Recipes for 3D Printing and Earth Architecture.

He has also presented a TED talk on ‘Borderwall as Architecture’ and has been the subject of several documentary films including those produced by The Museum of Modern Art, KQED, The New Yorker, and Mud Frontier: Architecture at the Borderlands bythe Cooper Hewitt Smithsonian Design Museum.

Transcript

From YouTube’s automatic captions, lightly cleaned; expect some errors. Each timestamp opens the video at that moment.

Read the full transcript · 4,005 words

0:03 Thank you, Duann. I’m going to take you on a reflection of work that we’ve done over the last 15 years related to architecture, both a geographic place but also a material place, and it begins with mankind’s oldest manufacturing material, which is mud, particularly from my own becoming mud bricks, and I’ve always been interested growing up in mud houses about the way that technologies come together around this material, which seems in some ways very pure, but because of its purity is infected by the collisions between technology, between culture, between design, and we see, for examples, building made of mud that are military forts. We see the oldest buildings in the United States and the oldest buildings in the world made out of mud, and it’s those collisions that are very interesting, the collisions of technology, when we see that over the time how a building constructed in the 1700s with the arrival of the railroad transforms, and with the arrival of ideas about what culture is transformed as well, and how these buildings give birth to other sorts of designs, given transformations and culture.

1:18 For example, these earthen buildings in New Mexico transform the moment that people started leaving villages to work in factories, into low riders, taking this code of eviscerating the the insides of these churches and taking them on a journey, to working in factories and mines around the country, and also how new technologies are being formed to supply the demand for mud bricks for the construction of homes in the Southwest.

1:48 In my own architecture practice, I’ve built buildings made out of mud. I think the first adobe building ever constructed out of mud in Marfa, Texas, in 80 years, which is in some ways not only architecture but archeology, and we can see in the archeology of the house the layers and stratification of geology that comes from the United States, and it comes from Mexico, and the performance criteria of that. So the bottom layer of mud is actually much stronger and but more expensive mud brick and the upper layer is less expensive but, and not as strong, but more lightweight, to make buildings that are potentially culturally and environmentally responsive, but also start to question and cross borders between what we think architecture is and what we think art is.

2:40 For example, this project I worked on with the artist Elmer Green and drag set in 2004, that is a simulation of a protest, or, built in the middle of the desert, entirely constructed of mud. My own practice is also embarked on this recently, almost completed, it should complete in July, enormous labyrinth made out of 40 000 mud bricks, constructed by my own community in Southern Colorado, and I’ve worked on the preservation of earthen buildings throughout the Southwest, thinking about how these, some of the oldest structures in the United States, could be healed, and how we understand how we can teach through these buildings history. We can teach indigenous and traditional technologies, not only building technologies but cooking technologies, and to think about how manufacturing processes or building processes can be transformative.

3:39 Recently I started working with the American Refugee Committee on thinking about how these traditional earthen ovens can be constructed in migrant shelters along the U.S., Mexico border, using an inflatable mold that was manufactured that could be packed with mud around it, so we can bring cooking technologies to migrant shelters very quickly, in places where people arrive and need to gather around these cooking technologies that migrated from Europe 400 years ago, ways to build community.

4:11 So earth has been a big part of my legacy, and in 2008 I wrote a book called Earth Architecture that looks at earth not as a traditional building process but as a modern building process, and that modern architecture has been made of earth. In the afterword of this book, I speculated on what might be the future of earthen construction, and I postulated that it might be 3D printing, and I wanted to be the person who embarked on that journey to see if it could be, and the project that we embarked upon was called Emerging Objects.

4:48 Emerging Objects: foundation, sustainable sources. We could create assembly methods that do not require specialized skills. We could create platforms for software and hardware that place added manufacturing within reach, and we can consider the connection between pre-industrial, industrial, and digital craft technologies. We can mesh those together so that we can look forward by learning from the past.

5:12 And in 2009 I began to think about how we can take mankind’s oldest manufacturing material, clay, which had been around for 30 000 years, and think about its future. And so some of the earliest experiments were using binder jet printing to make ceramic objects and speculating on what those ceramic objects might be that we sort of, bricks that are slightly more intelligent and hold plants, could we make insulative bricks or passive cooling bricks that store water in the porosity of the material, the cool buildings, as buildings have been cooled with ceramic vessels for thousands of years. But thinking about, in the same way, how you can gather a material from a localized place and build a building with it, what are the other local materials that exist that you might make a building with?

6:05 And one of these materials, in the San Francisco Bay Area where I was located, is salt. And if you ever flown into the Bay Area, you see these enormous crystallization ponds, and they’re multicolored because the microorganisms that live within them. But Emerging Objects developed a 3D printing building material made out of salt, and because it was quite inexpensive and had really interesting material properties, we began to think and speculate about what it meant to aggregate those, and what it meant to make buildings out of those, inspired by landscapes made out of salt, and also inspired by places in the world where you take the landscape itself to build buildings. How could you make new structures with the materials that are available?

6:48 So one experiment was an, called an igloo made out of salt a salty glue, because it was basically made out of salt and glue, made out of a series of components that were binder jet out of salt, and these are all experiments to think about what kinds of structures could you make, lightweight structures held in tension, a sort of lightweight salt tent, to experiment with the possibilities of creating enclosure using local, inexpensive materials that only use the sun and the wind to generate.

7:22 Another local material takes on the challenge of the seven billion tons of wood waste that are generated each year from the construction industry, and how we can transform that into an additive manufacturing material, again always thinking about the locality of the material, the sawmills in this case, and the Sierra Nevadas in California, thinking about their modularity because of the size of the machines that are available, to creating farms of these machines to produce parts that could create walls, enclosures, and building systems, an Emerging Object launched another company called Forest, and the Forest began to focus on the added manufacturing wood, and explored the ways that binderjet technology could transform wood, not in a natural way but in a very unnatural way, to emulate the grains of wood, because we could print them within the thickness of the material itself, and to produce different kinds of objects.

8:18 And I thought I’d show a gyroid guitar, since we were talking about gyro, July I don’t know what this might have been made with, anthropology, I don’t remember but this Forest is now part of the Desktop Metal ecosystem, and now there are these large Forest addition Desktop Metal printers that can print these wooden objects, because this is architecture that we’re always focused on.

8:41 Cement is also a material that we’ve explored, but rather than using large amounts of water and wood to make formwork, how could printing processes make very low water use, formless building components, using Portland cement, always looking forward at the possibility of this material, and always looking back to think about the technologies that have come before us, to explore what might launch these materials into the future. But the basis for these explorations is always mud.

9:16 And in 2016 we launched a project called G-Code Clay. It was the beginnings of a now ubiquitous printing movement in ceramics project, but developed into a project that considered aesthetics, considered structure, considered the potential for how a robot moves, and to think about a new paradigm of design where we are not, as Juan said, designing the object, but designing the tool path through which the object moves, through which the robot moves, and thinking about their possibilities for enclosure, structure, texture, surface, pattern, and again always thinking about the cultural implications.

10:03 And while I was giving a lecture on this back in 2017, the leader of the previous regime had announced and I was giving this lecture in El Paso, Texas how there were a lot of bad ombres at the U.S., Mexico border. And so I thought it interesting to think about how sophisticated that gesture was, that there wasn’t a lot of bad hombres at the border, bad men, there are a lot of bad ombres, and bad hombres is this gradient between light and dark, and I so I assume that’s the bad ombre and that’s a good ombre. So, using this technology, made a series of objects called Bad Hombres, which looked at clays from different political regions around the United States and blended them together to show how a single object can show a kind of heterogeneity, a movement away from homogeneity of materials in the building industry, which asked the question of how can we take the earth from the site it’s not bought in stores at a clay store but the actual soil from the site, to think about how we might build the future.

11:06 In 2018 we’re invited by Google to Mumbai to explore a project called Future Relics, a project that explored the making of a series of objects today that would have relevance a hundred years from now. Google had made this program where people will be keen into the Mumbai Museum could choose the most important word they thought that one should consider in a hundred years, and it would imprinted on a digital pod, and then Emerging Objects would produce those pots for an exhibition that would take place at the British Museum in 100 years. And originally they wanted us to produce those pots in California and ship them to India, which we thought was ridiculous, and instead asked if we could work with one of the most famous potters in India, using Indian clay to develop these pots and work hyper locally with this part of their Panaji, who they’re showing this clay he harvested in his studio, and we produced a series of pots that had words like plastic, or book, or cell phone. And after the exhibition, one of the words was 3D printing that should be considered, and these were manufactured with the 3D printer, but also hand glazed by Panajit himself. So if you’re around, in I guess how many years is that, 93 years, for the exhibition, the British Museum, I encourage you to attend.

12:34 That led to a project of thinking about how we can think about the heterogeneity of clay, the diversities of clay that exist in the landscape, and this is a project called Future Ruins, that we invited 25 potters between the United States and Mexico, mostly from Juarez and El Paso, to walk along the border and collect traditional plays and collect this diverse complexions and qualities of clays. And we also made available the coding that allowed us to create these highly textured objects, and we created a software called Potterware, and you can see that at potterdware.com, that’s used around universities and colleges and high schools around the world now. And it was a way for potters to enter into the 3D printed world quite quickly, because potters have a very different skill set learning how to model, learning how to slice, learning how to run a printer is very difficult but this is the underlying basis for thinking about how we can design with tool paths rather than design objects. And that allowed us to think about how we might create structure at a much larger scale, and so those 25 potters, over the course of several weeks, made over 250 pots using the clay of the local region.

13:51 So this relationship between the machine, between culture, between place, was carried out in a project called Sam’s Le Mans if you speak French, I just butchered that but, without the hand, and we’re invited to create a structure that explored this concept of building with France today, or traditionally in France, and used local clays to apply them to this armature that had this highly textured surface that would then create this very stable, experimental structure, of thinking about how the combination with of a very thin bioplastic, attached with clay, would create a stiffening to create this structure.

14:33 So many of the experiments led to habitats. Habitats not only for people, but habitats for animals, habitats that could use these kinds of textures to create cooling shells and structural shells, for a very rare bird that’s endangered off the coast of California. And so, working with scientists, we developed this design for this synthetic bird nest, for these birds that have lost their habitat, and some of the criteria was had to remain a certain temperature, it had to drain, because of the because birds poop and pee, and stray sea lion might lay upon it so these were some of the criterias for making these, and also the scientists had to stick their hand in and be able to monitor the chicks. And so these are some of the experiments that are now being studied on the Farallones Islands, off of the coast of California.

15:30 The Academy of Sciences in San Francisco visited and saw these various materials, and asked if we could make a produce coral reef scans out of calcium carbonate, not because calcium carbonate is a good substrate to grow coral, but in fact they wanted to demonstrate, as an educational tool, how calcium carbonate dissolves with higher pH water because of a global warming. But when they saw these weird, loopy ceramics, they mentioned that those were the ideal substrates for coral growth on ceramic, and we produced over 4 000 different ceramic 3D printed objects for testing in places around the world for coral larvae growth, and now these are scattered throughout the oceans in the world, with success with the technique, for just being the habitat for a single coral larvae to grow upon. And our goal is to produce a million of these in the near future, to promote coral reef development throughout the oceans.

16:37 One example of a human habitat from 2018 was the Cabin of 3D Printed Curiosities, where we combined many of these technologies to think about how we could take advantage of a relaxation in the building codes in the San Francisco Bay Area, where you can now build up to 1200 square feet without going to an architect, or without going to the city and applying for a building permit. So we use that as an opportunity to think about how 3D printing, using these kind of techniques, could address the housing crisis in the Bay Area, producing ceramic 3D printing cladding materials, materials made out of recycled sawdust, recycled cement, recycled salt, and recycled Chardonnay grape skins from the wineries in the San Francisco Bay Area, to make building facades and building components. And this is the Cabin of 3D Printed Curiosities that uses all these techniques, making the furniture, making the cladding, making the lighting systems. I believe you can even see a 3D printed coffee cup made out of recycled coffee, and the various processes that might go into creating a house that’s not a singular house made out of concrete, for example, one material, but a house that’s heterogeneous, that has many different kinds of materials that apply to our many different kind of spatial sensibilities: translucency, rough, smooth, soft, hard, and the different kinds of environments and qualities we might want in a place to live.

18:10 But again, the goal is to think about how we might build at scale using mud, and so many of those early experiments are experiments, not thinking about these small objects, despite their beauty and their texture, but perhaps this is the goal. And about six years ago we begin a collaboration with a company called 3D Potter that manufactured ceramic 3D printers, to develop a much larger scale printer, much larger scale printer, to print with earth. The result was this it’s now a commercialized 3D printer that’s very low cost, let’s say, large-scale manufacturing of ceramic objects, but also print very large objects. And so many questions were raised then: how do you pump huge amounts of earth through a printer, and how do you increase the quality of a 3D print that’s using mud, and what might be the outcomes of that endeavor? Could we print houses in the future that are not made out of concrete, but which are made out of man’s oldest building material for housing, which is earth?

19:20 With the success of the development of both the software, which is the underlying basis for Potterware, the hardware, which is the Scara low-tech robot, and the technologies of pushing mud, in 2019 merging objects started a project called Mud Frontiers, in which the first time in the history in the Western Hemisphere were 3D printing mud that’s taken from a local source and deposited right on site. And so many of those experiments experimented with the potential of printing with mud and how it might be different. Many earthen buildings are very, very thick, but because we could corrugate earth, we could print very thin shells. This structure right here is only an inch and a half thick, and about eight feet tall, and and is five years old, and last month it sat in a foot of water for about three weeks because high snow falls during the winter created floods in this area, and it still survives today.

20:21 Printed ideas and thoughts for thinking about how you could print stairways, or create insulated cavities for earth that don’t use enormous masses of earth, but have air spaces and pockets. Began to think about how we might use some of these experiments to make local pottery using local soils, different kinds of structural strategies that are also aesthetic strategies, using local materials like cedar that would bind to very thin walls to make a thicker wall together, but create this kind of texture, and thinking about how we might start to build in program, or what architects called program: places to sit, places together, places to work around.

21:01 And during COVID, when the university was closed and you could go out and do whatever you want, I returned to this very rural environment where I did many of the experiments, and did many more experiments thinking about how we might build vaults, or domes, or tribulated structures that create openings without headers or lentils. And to think about how that same idea of a low-cost technology could make a very low cost rail, a fourth axis in robotics, placing and moving this lightweight rail in different locations to make multicellular a multicellular structure, I mean, in a structure with rooms with this inexpensive robot that we’re hacking in different ways. We want to print taller, just put it on a big wood box, drive it from the cell phone, dig dirt from just a few feet away, mix it and put it in the, through the pump, and create structural possibilities for 3D printing with earth.

22:11 The result of that experiment was a project called Casa Kovida. Kovidad isn’t really a word, but it was it looks like kovid, but it also could mean cohabitation, kovida but it’s a house for cohabitation during the time of COVID. And this is that house, which is learning from traditional indigenous technologies, taking earth from the site, thinking about how you might build enclosures for sleeping and gathering, cooking, using traditional pottery and methods that have been materials have been used for thousands of years in the region places for making connections between the earth and the sky, places for bathing, and and because many people ask me, well, what about a roof, I thought about what a roof might be, in hybrid technology structure, in this case an inflatable roof that imparted this beautiful quality of light into the structure, sort of a cherry on top of this chocolate sundae of a house.

23:13 Last year I was invited to make a large-scale installation at the Frontier Drive-In. The frontier driving is in very rural Colorado, it’s a 1955 era drive-in theater that’s being restored in an extremely rural site, tons of or large amounts of center pivot sprinklers that draw deep from the aquifers below, producing wheat and barley for some of the beer companies in Colorado, all started in silos. And so the project is called Skylos, it’s again this contemplation between earth and sky, the silos of earth that hold the sky, in this dark sky environment, and it’s the first 3D printed earthen structure that’s been permitted in the world, and engineered, built with a very small team, three people, that uses this very low-cost robot, earth from the site, and a building material that’s ubiquitous and free.

24:22 Foreign. Just four months ago, because of the success of many of these projects, I’ve had the great opportunity to ramp up the kind of production, and so now I have the opportunity to use this quite amazing ABB robot mounted to a 25 foot long trailer that moves up and down this track, that makes it highly mobile, highly portable, and the potential to build much larger structures far more quickly than I had in the past. And so one of the experiments I just left yesterday was the construction of the world’s first Nubian Vault. This is a parabolic vault that uses no formwork to support itself, it’s because of the paraboloid shape, it’s and our ability to print non-planarly we’re testing to see if it’s possible to 3D print not only the walls of a structure but a roof of a structure, that has been, like, has been done on this planet for millennium.

25:30 So this is the Endeavor, embarking upon the idea that perhaps the way forward in architecture is to learn from the past, to think about how we might challenge the paradigms of construction using added manufacturing today, that for 99 of the time are employing a material that has demonstrated to have an enormous carbon footprint on our planet, and instead use a building material that is carbon zero, that is inexpensive, that is ubiquitous, and to think about how we can use additive manufacturing, and to think about it in a way that employs traditional and Indigenous knowledge to build the future, and respond to a very interesting proposition proposed by the Smithsonian Magazine, on their 40th anniversary, when they thought about the 40 most important things you should know about the next 40 years, and the number one thing they mentioned that we should know about is that sophisticated buildings will be made out of mud. Thank you very much. Come on.

More from CDFAM NYC 2023

Design Computation Human

Design Computation Human

Onur Yüce Gün · New Balance

Roadmap to Replicators

Roadmap to Replicators

Neil Gershenfeld · MIT Center for Bits and Atoms

Scaling & Standardizing Patient Specific Design

Scaling & Standardizing Patient Specific Design

Adam Wentworth · Mayo Clinic

Computational Design Ops

Computational Design Ops

Ronnie Parsons · Mode Lab

Overcoming the Design Dilemma

Overcoming the Design Dilemma

Ryan Carter · Johns Hopkins APL

Generative Design & Digital Manufacturing at NASA Goddard

Generative Design & Digital Manufacturing at NASA Goddard

Ryan McClelland · NASA Goddard Space Flight Center

Digital Materials – Geometry and Data Combined

Digital Materials – Geometry and Data Combined

Marek Moffett · General Lattice

Ten Years Teaching Additive

Ten Years Teaching Additive

John Hart · MIT

10 Years of Applying DFAM

10 Years of Applying DFAM

Tim Simpson · Penn State University

MfAM Walks so DfAM Can Run!

MfAM Walks so DfAM Can Run!

Chelsea Cummings · The Barnes Global Advisors

Informatics and AI for Materials Development

Informatics and AI for Materials Development

Wes John Alder · Citrine Informatics

Predicting Fatigue Life in AM Metal Parts Using DigitalClone

Predicting Fatigue Life in AM Metal Parts Using DigitalClone

Behrooz Jalalahmadi · Sentient Science

Designing Material Properties with Advanced Toolpath Generation

Designing Material Properties with Advanced Toolpath Generation

Alex Roschli · Oak Ridge National Laboratory

Design Automation Using Machine Learning & Computational Design

Design Automation Using Machine Learning & Computational Design

Rhushik Matroja · Cognitive Design Systems

Learning to Generate Shapes

Learning to Generate Shapes

Karl Willis · Autodesk Research

Design for Artificial Intelligence

Design for Artificial Intelligence

Chris McComb · Carnegie Mellon University

Register for Updates and Discounts on CDFAM events.